At midnight today Whatsapp stopped working in Brazil and will be like this for 48 hours. A judge in São Paulo has ordered that the service be shut down due to the app failing to comply with a criminal investigation earlier this year. Or at least this is the reason given in the media. The party that solicited the suspension of the service has not been disclosed due to this alleged criminal investigation.
Okay. What I keep wondering about is if the punishment really fits the crime here. The whole population is now paying for something that the company hasn’t done — and again, this is all very secretive and we have no idea why this is happening — but many people depend of the app to go about their lives and businesses. I have my groups of students and reaching them using another medium isn’t impossible, but troublesome for sure.
People on social media have been talking about it since yesterday but I believe the point being made is the wrong one. Countless memes have been posted on Facebook about how lost people will be without Whatsapp and how productive people will actually be in these two days because of the time they will have in their hands to focus on their job. But I believe this is the wrong approach. Instead of trying to circumvent the ban by downloading patches or other apps, people should have made their preference being heard loud and clear. What is this all about? Why am I being punished for someone else’s alleged crime? Why is my business being hurt because of this decision?
Some people have gone political on it:
But one of those memes has expressed my frustration with this country in a perfect way:
Update: An appeals court have just overturned the decision and the app is back on. The reason for that was that millions are being punished for what a company did or did not do… Embarrassing for the first judge who ordered the shut down…